Shumaila Hussain Shahani and Disha Verma
As tensions between India and Pakistan escalated following a terrorist attack in India-administered Kashmir on April 22, 2025, misinformation ran rife on broadcast and online spaces on both sides of the border. Social media was flooded with unverified claims of drone attacks, explosions, captures, mock drills, and more. A combination of television broadcasters rampantly misreporting events with impunity and social media platforms brimming with new, unverified updates by the second created an unprecedented information environment of dread, anxiety, and paralyzing fear for close to two weeks.
In desperate attempts to streamline this feral flow of information, both governments invoked sweeping legislative powers to censor, block, and stifle online speech – except the attempts were demonstratively partisan, excessive, and chilling, even for actors who had no active role in this misinformation war. This episode is the most recent of many examples of how a technology once hailed for democratizing knowledge has increasingly become a leash in the hands of states. Online spaces are now fertile grounds for unbridled control, giving rise to the concept of “digital authoritarianism.” This problem is not unique to India and Pakistan by any means, but both governments – long flagged by human rights groups as digital authoritarian regimes – flexed that muscle in full public view during the April-May escalations.
In India, the result was mass censorship at an unprecedented scale. Over 8,000 accounts belonging to media houses, journalists, and individual users – homed largely in Pakistan but also in India, China, Turkiye, and Bangladesh – were withheld on X, Pakistani creators and news channels on YouTube and Spotify were geoblocked, and websites of independent Indian news publications suspended without reason. After X reported having received requests from the Indian government to suspend the 8,000+ accounts, the official X account itself was briefly withheld and then restored in mere hours – marking a unique and bizarre instance of platforms geoblocking themselves.