20 November 2026

What’s Your WAR? Moneyballing Professional Military Education

Small Wars Journal | Col. Patrick McCarthy

Col. Patrick McCarthy examines the current state of professional military education through an analytical lens inspired by baseball sabermetrics. Professional military education relies heavily on administrative outputs like credit hours and graduation rates rather than measuring true value added to an officer's capability. A 2020 Government Accountability Office review found that while programs meet civilian accreditation standards, the Office of the Secretary of Defense remains poorly positioned to assess their actual effectiveness.

Organizations must adopt outcome-based metrics that evaluate real professional growth rather than assuming career advancement equates to educational impact. Future assessments should track educational value added through diagnostic baselines and monitor repetition to ensure programs actually develop enduring strategic judgment.

Comment

Institutional evaluation within professional military education routinely substitutes administrative volume for operational capability. Counting credit hours or graduation rates obscures whether an officer's strategic judgment actually improved under academic scrutiny.

Assessing retention of cognitive skills requires moving beyond terminal grades to measure diagnostic baselines against culminating outcomes, mirroring how CJCSM 1810.01A attempts to structure joint professional military education certification.

Strategic Question for Discussion
What happens to institutional accountability when graduation rates are treated as a reliable proxy for strategic competence?
The pattern suggests institutions optimize for accreditation compliance rather than operational adaptability. This disconnect leaves commands ill-prepared for complex strategic environments.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
πŸ’¬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×