19 November 2026

The Case for a Trump-Xi-Putin Summit

Foreign Affairs | Charles Kupchan

Russian President Vladimir Putin floated a proposed three-way summit with U.S. President Donald Trump and Chinese leader Xi Jinping on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation meeting in Shenzhen, China. According to The Wall Street Journal, Putin suggested the trialogue as an opportunity to discuss ending the war in Ukraine.

The prospect of trilateral talks has generated immediate international concern regarding great-power bargaining. Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski warned against repeating the 1945 Yalta Conference, where major powers divided spheres of influence. Diplomatic logistics and complex summit arrangements remain unconfirmed, as no firm plan has been formally announced by the participating governments. European allies fear bilateral or trilateral concessions could compromise Ukrainian sovereignty and regional security architecture. High-stakes negotiations face severe political friction. The upcoming APEC gathering highlights shifting geopolitical dynamics among Washington, Beijing, and Moscow as leaders navigate diplomatic positioning.

Comment

Great-power summitry conducted outside institutional alliance structures undermines collective security commitments across NATO's eastern flank. By pursuing direct trilateral negotiation formats, summit proposals bypass the North Atlantic Council, leaving frontline member states vulnerable to unilateral diplomatic bargaining. This dynamic threatens to institutionalise security peripheralisation for frontline states along the Suwalki Gap.

As a downstream consequence, eastern European capitals will likely accelerate autonomous bilateral defence pacts and regional procurement initiatives outside standard NATO common funding. Such fragmentation weakens unified force planning under Allied Command Operations while increasing regional friction over intelligence-sharing protocols.

Strategic Question for Discussion
Which carries greater risk for NATO cohesion — the formal bypass of the North Atlantic Council in great-power summitry, or the resulting shift toward uncoordinated bilateral defence pacts along the Suwalki Gap?
The available evidence points toward bilateral defence fragmentation as the more persistent vulnerability. While top-level summitry creates immediate political alarm, the long-term erosion of standardized force integration under Allied Command Operations poses deeper operational risks to regional deterrence.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
💬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×