10 October 2017

Amazing Grace

In 1990 I got posted to Binnaguri. Binnaguri is located in North Bengal with tea gardens all around. Binnaguri military station is a sprawling complex housing a complete division. Probably it was the only station which had three mountain brigades, one arty brigade, all Div troop units and two animal transport companies at one complex. We had all the facilities in terms of a golf course, swimming pool, tennis court, club, picture hall etc. Those days there was no TV, All India radio did not reach Binnaguri, no cable TV, forget about mobile phones no STD telephones. We had Kendriya Vidyalaya with no teachers in science stream. Our children used to play outside during the science class hours. Grass used to grow at the rate of 6 inches per day. One could not complete the grass cutting especially at the golf course. On top of it, we had a GOC from Gorkha Rifles the then Maj Gen P S Bammi. I need not say anything more for those who knew him. Within a week of my joining, with full battle load the complete division had a 90 km route march from Binnaguri to Coronation Bridge. People still talk about Ex Shah Sawar.

Since there was nothing better to do, lot of emphasis was on training, professional and sports competitions and regimental functions. Buddha Baba was the favourite hooch.

I was posted as Sparrow of Shakti Vijay Brigade. Brig Inder Aggarwal from Rajput Regiment had just taken over the command of the brigade from the then Brig and later Lt Gen Johnny Mukherjee. In my service, I have not seen a better soldier than Johnny Mukherjee. In a neighbouring brigade we had two Rajput battalions – 22 and 27. Inder Aggarwal commanded 22 Rajput earlier. He became the local Col of both the battalions. 

22 Rajput was also commanded by handlebar moustached Lt Gen Mukesh Sabharwal. He was my Corps Commander at Srinagar when I was a Sparrow at 15 Corps. I had the unique experience of partnering him in a doubles semi finals in a tennis tournament in Srinagar and ended up winning against much younger opponents. But let me not digress. In OP Rhino I had the privilege to work with 22 Rajput. P K Singh (later Maj Gen), Ravi Jhaldiyal (probably a Maj Gen now) and others were great guys to work with. I’ll leave this story for another day.  

16 Sikh Li was part of our brigade. It was commanded by Col (later Brig) Ranjeet Singh. He came to command the unit after a tenure as AQMG at IMTRAT. It is very difficult to find a more resourceful person than him. The then Lt Col Bikram Singh, later COAS came as 2nd in command of the unit. Lt Col Bikram Singh was physically very fit and tough and led his troops in BPET. I had an opportunity to be with 16 Sigh Li at Dukhey Dzong in Bhutan during training. I shall share my experience with Ranjeet Singh and his paltan sometime later. 

It was adam inspection of 16 Sikh Li. The regimental dinner night was the last event. You could trust Col Ranjeet Singh, it would be a gala affair. With full regimental regalia everything was rehearsed to the perfection. With every course of the meal, a different tune was played by the band. It was perfectly synchronised. When everything was over I asked him how did he manage the exquisite timing? He was gracious enough to show me the switch under his table where he sat by which he used to ring a bell to the band for the next tune to be played! 

When we came out of the dinning hall at the open lawn, it was the last event. The head of the military band gave a smart salute to the Brigade Commander and requested him for a tune which they will play. Somehow I think Brig Inder Aggarwal had a soft corner for me. He turned towards me and said it is Sparrow’s choice. 

I am not a musical person. I had no idea about tunes to be played by a military band, I only knew Sara Jahan se Accha, Deshon Ka Sartaj Bharat at the most Colonel Bogey. I was stumped. Suddenly something struck me, I had heard somewhere the words Amazing Grace. I blurted out Amazing Grace. Brig Inder Aggarwal paused, took out the pipe he was smoking, gave me a benign smile and told me how did I know that it was his favourite tune as well? 

Every Military band in Indian Army knows Amazing Grace backwards and the band of Sikh Light Infantry Regiment played Amazing Grace. It was surreal atmosphere.

P.S. Much later after my tenure at Baramula, I was posted as OC Junior Wing at MCTE Mhow looking after the young officers' training. I used to take the class of military music myself, starting with this episode. I made a handout on military music which used to be given to every young officer of the Corps of Signals. Later, in 2012, I had the privilege of visiting AEC Centre and School Panchmarhi. As per me this is the only Cat A establishment which has incorporated latest technology in all their curriculum. The way music is being taught to the musicians of the three armed forces is a treat to watch. But then they are under disbandment which is another story.

Assessing ASEAN’s “Non-interference” principle: A lost cause for Rohingyas?

By Anant Mishra

One of the principle fundamentals of ASEAN is its “non-interference” principle which plays a key role in its extensive interaction with member countries. The principle is highlighted in the ASEAN’s “Treaty of Amity and Cooperation” Article 2(c), which came into existence in 1976. The purpose of this principle is to ensure cooperation, coordination and correlation among member nations while observing “respect to each sovereign member country”, while retaining “domestic issues”

New U.S. helicopters mark major change for Afghan air force

Josh Smith

A Blackhawk helicopter flies above a parked A-29 Super Tucano aircraft, during a handover ceremony of Blackhawk helicopters from U.S. to the Afghan forces, at the Kandahar Air. Senior Afghan and American officials welcomed the arrival of new U.S.-made military helicopters on Saturday, beginning a process that will radically transform the young Afghan air force.

A Military History of Afghanistan: From the Great Game to the Global War on Terror

 by Ali Ahmad Jalali

Afghanistan is many things. It may – or may not – be a graveyard of empires, depending on which end of the shovel you happen to be on. It is definitely one of the lands that produces more military history than can be consumed locally. Afghanistan is, for its size, one of the most diverse and complex countries on earth. The foreigners that end up waging war there usually do not understand Afghanistan. 

Afghanistan and Strategy: A Perspective 16 Years On

By Robert Cassidy

"No one starts a war – or rather, no one in his senses ought to do so – without first being clear in his mind what he intends to achieve by that war and how he intends to conduct it.” Carl von Clausewitz

Pakistan’s ISI thwarts US plans in Afghanistan

By Commodore C Uday Bhaskar (Retd.)

Almost 16 years to the day since the US embarked upon its war on terrorism against the Afghan Taliban on October 7, 2001 as reprisal for the enormity of the 9/11 terrorist attacks, it appears that a White House administration is again issuing dire warnings to Rawalpindi (GHQ of the Pakistan Army) while still dangling the familiar ‘carrot.’ 

Time for another Strike against Pakistan

By Brig Anil Gupta

The recent terrorist attack on a Border Security Force (BSF) Battalion Headquarters in Srinagar has confirmed three things beyond doubt. Firstly; in Pakistan alias Atankistan, the Army continues to call the shots and not the civilian government led by a dummy prime minister. Secondly; the realm of Indo-Pak relations does not fall in the domain of foreign policy but continues to be an adjunct of defence policy and hence is formulated in General Head Quarters (GHQ) Rawalpindi and not at Islamabad by the Foreign Minister. Thirdly, Pakistan Army unashamedly continues to use terror as an instrument of policy against India disregarding the international opinion and UN pronouncements. 

Pakistan September 2017: State of the Nation & its Regional Implications

By Dr Subhash Kapila

Pakistan in September 2017 perceptionaly appears in an existential crisis wherein all major pillars of state stand engulfed in a systemic failure likely to endanger regional security and a crisis from which Pakistan cannot retrieve itself without a change of existing mindsets by Pakistan’s policy establishment.

Trump's Dangerous Twitter Rebuke of Tillerson May Make Diplomacy Impossible With North Korea

By Ankit Panda

U.S. President Donald Trump’s remarkable decision to rebuke his own secretary of state’s attempt at pursuing diplomacy with North Korea last week was a dangerous move at a dangerous time.

Strategic Contours of China’s Arms Exports

By Michael Raska


China’s global geopolitical aspirations, backed by growing economic clout, shape the direction and character of its military-technological choices and China’s strategic interest to strengthen its position in global arms markets.

Military Reform in China

Of the many noteworthy developments that have characterised Chinese President Xi Jinping’s first five-year term, none stands out as much as military reform, and this reveals a great deal about the coming political trajectory in China, writes political analyst Cheng Li.

Xi Jinping did not shy from the bold and broad undertaking of military reform and it has resulted in profound changes to the People’s Liberation Army (PLA).

After the fall of ISIS, what’s next for counterterrorism?

William McCants
Source Link

As ISIS continues to lose territory in Iraq and Syria, leaders in the region and the West will need to develop a new counterterrorism strategy to adapt to the group’s decentralization. Europe, meanwhile, has seen a surge of ISIS-claimed terrorist attacks on its own soil. In the context of these new challenges, experts on counterterrorism gathered at the 2017 U.S.-Islamic World Forum to discuss what governments, civil society, and the private sector can do.

ISIS Fighters, Having Pledged to Fight or Die, Surrender en Masse


DIBIS, Iraq — The prisoners were taken to a waiting room in groups of four, and were told to stand facing the concrete wall, their noses almost touching it, their hands bound behind their backs.

Toward a NATO of the Gulf? The Challenges of Collective Defense Within the GCC

Dr Jean-Loup Samaan
Source Link

Although collective security in the Gulf is the topic of numerous policy publications, most of the available literature focuses on the political environment without considering the operational requirements of this scenario. This monograph offers an evaluation of Gulf defense cooperation programs in order to stir the discussion on the future of the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) as the “NATO of the Gulf.”

You Have To Hear What Keeps The Head Of U.S. Strategic Command Up At Night

Source Link

Out of all the presentations and panels at this year's Air Force Association convention, one speaker in particular had a most important, brave, and sobering message. A message that goes against the "company man" attitude we seem to find in many of the military's top brass, and one that deals with something we here at The War Zone have been talking about for a long, long time. Instead of worrying about Kim Jong Un's missiles or Putin's huge nuclear arsenal, what keeps the head of Strategic Command, General John Hyten, up at night is the cold hard fact that America's defense industrial complex has lost the ability to "go fast."

Russian Hackers Stole NSA Data on U.S. Cyber Defense

by Gordon Lubold and Shane Harris

Hackers working for the Russian government stole details of how the U.S. penetrates foreign computer networks and defends against cyberattacks after a National Security Agency contractor removed the highly classified material and put it on his home computer, according to multiple people with knowledge of the matter.

The hackers appear to have targeted the contractor after identifying the files through the contractor’s use of a popular antivirus software made by Russia-based Kaspersky Lab, these people said.

The Myth of Accidental War

By James H Nolt

As the rhetoric and warlike maneuvers of the U.S. and North Korea accelerate, the media are increasingly considering the prospect of “accidental” war between the U.S. and North Korea. But if war does start, it will not be accidental. It depends on deliberate choices by both sides about whether to escalate violence or pull back and reassess. Those choices are made by politicians, who are often swayed by domestic political pressures. economy when considering war origins. Clausewitz hoped that valid reasons of state security would guide decisions for war. He did not claim that they typically do.

Fighting Russia’s “Factory of Lies”, the Internet Research Agency

David Filipov

She rode into a pitch-black truck stop on a scooter, stepped out of the pouring rain into a gas station cafe on the outskirts of St. Petersburg and recounted her quest to bring down Russia’s infamous “troll farm.”

Lyudmila Savchuk is one of a disparate handful of Russian journalists, activists and legal experts who have tried to shed light on the shadowy operation that has become a focal point of U.S. investigations into Kremlin meddling in the 2016 presidential election.

Is Amazon Or Alibaba Winning The ECommerce Wars

While Amazon is much more innovative, Alibaba has huge growth potential on their home turf.

Hello, mobile operators? This is your age of disruption calling

Difficult times for operators call for questioning old orthodoxies to win.

For the better part of a decade, telecom companies have suffered through declining revenues, cash flow, and return on investment just as tech companies like Google, Facebook, Amazon, and others have mushroomed by building their businesses on the operators’ own infrastructure. While these tech visionaries have enjoyed well over $1 trillion in combined market-cap growth by innovating and thinking differently and adeptly, telecom companies have tried to compete by implementing the same old survival tactics: cutting costs, reducing the workforce, and timidly entering into new business adjacencies. The trouble is that playbook no longer applies.

Cyber Spending Expected to Increase

The Defense Department recently elevated U.S. Cyber Command to a full-fledged, unified combatant command, as threats in the digital domain continue to grow. However, the long-term budgetary implications of the move remain unclear, said a leading analyst.

Mediation Perspectives: The Myanmar Peace Process 2011-2015 Through National Glasses

By Rachel Gasser

Mediation Perspectives is a periodic blog entry that’s provided by the CSS’ Mediation Support Team and occasional guest authors. Each entry is designed to highlight the utility of mediation approaches in dealing with violent political conflicts. To keep up to date with the Mediation Support Team, you can sign up to their newsletter here.

America's Autopilot Wars

By Andrew Bacevich

Consider, if you will, these two indisputable facts. First, the United States is today more or less permanently engaged in hostilities in not one faraway place, but at least seven. Second, the vast majority of the American people could not care less. 

Nor can it be said that we don’t care because we don’t know. True, government authorities withhold certain aspects of ongoing military operations or release only details that they find convenient. Yet information describing what U.S. forces are doing (and where) is readily available, even if buried in recent months by barrages of presidential tweets. Here, for anyone interested, are press releases issued by United States Central Command for just one recent week:

The Key Powers´ Construction of the Mediterranean

How should the EU balance its own policies and interests in the Mediterranean against those of other major and regional powers? To find out, this publication examines the role and influence of eight leading stakeholders in the Mediterranean, including the US, Russia, China, Iran, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Turkey and Israel. More specifically, the text´s authors look at how these actors 1) perceive the Mediterranean; 2) interact with the EU, states, non-state actors and international organizations with regard to the region; and 3) pursue their national interests in the region.

A reminder that we pay for our wars in money and blood

Larry Kummer

Summary: We ignore our wars (hardly mentioned in the campaigns). We pay for our wars, hot and cold, in two ways — in money and blood. Let’s look at the toll in both. This will be an unpopular post. Neither Left nor Right cares to look at the toll of our wars. Both prefer their poo-throwing fights.

What if the Crossing had Failed?


My name is Ben Levy. Lieutenant Colonel Shimon Ben Levy, of the historical branch of the Israeli General Staff. My boss, acting in the name of chief of staff General Rafael Eitan (”Raful,” as he is popularly known), has ordered me to do an interesting study: namely to inquire, as best I can, what might have happened if the 1973 Israeli crossing of the Suez Canal—arguably the most important move in the entire war—had failed. Why he wants the study I have no idea.