12 May 2025

Leo XIV: A New Kind of Pope for a New Kind of Catholic Church

Andrew Latham

The election of the first American pope, Leo XIV, is rightly seen as historic. But the real story is not his passport. It is how he positions the Church in relation to the world it now faces—and how that posture differs, in subtle but consequential ways, from the approaches of his three predecessors. Where John Paul II evangelized across continents, Benedict XVI defended doctrinal coherence, and Francis prioritized pastoral outreach and institutional reform, this pope signals something quieter but no less important: a recalibration of the Church’s bearing in an age of global fragmentation.

To understand this pope’s emerging stance, we need to locate it within the longer arc of recent papal history. John Paul II was a man of the Cold War. He understood—viscerally and politically—what was at stake in the ideological conflict between liberal democracy and Soviet totalitarianism. His papacy reflected that moment: global, confident, insistent that Catholicism could speak powerfully into the contest over the soul of modernity. Benedict XVI inherited that legacy but shifted the emphasis inward. Confronted with growing secularization and relativism, he focused on defending the integrity of faith, often against the grain of cultural trends. His was a papacy of ideas—brilliant, theologically rich, but often perceived as aloof.


No comments: