Matthew Continetti
Donald Trump’s diplomatic high-wire act never stops. The ceasefire between Israel and Hamas demands constant attention. The war between Russia and Ukraine is nowhere near a settlement. The trade war with China toggles off and on. U.S. forces target drug smugglers linked to Venezuela and Colombia.
As if all that weren’t enough, America risks alienating a key ally in our strategic competition with China.
The friend is India. A recent visit here as part of a delegation organized by the Hudson Institute and the India Foundation brought home the extent of the damage from tariffs, immigration restrictions, and most important, dealings with Pakistan. The Indian government, led by prime minister Narendra Modi, is struggling to understand and manage Trump’s sudden reversals, while the Indian public feels betrayed. The general sense is that the two democracies will weather the storm—but only if the United States comprehends the significance that India places on Pakistan, and acts accordingly.
Close ties between America and India weren’t and aren’t inevitable. They’re the result of strategic decisions on both sides. And they don’t come easily. After winning freedom from the British in 1947, India acted as the conscience of the Non-Aligned Movement, navigating an independent and often ambivalent course between West and East, between the Free World and the Communist bloc.
America found a more willing Cold War partner in Pakistan, the Muslim nation born out of partition from India, and against which India has fought four wars in 78 years. Pakistan served as an anti-Soviet check in South Asia. It acted as an intermediary between the United States and China. It was the staging ground for U.S. support for the mujahedeen fighting the Soviets in Afghanistan. The result was mistrust between America and India, a rare phenomenon for two countries that share common values, such as freedom and pluralism, as well as democratic institutions.
Things began to change at the approach of the millennium. The Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, around the time India opened its economy to free enterprise and foreign investment. Indian migration to the United States grew. And India became central to the back-office operations of major US corporations.
When both India and Pakistan joined the nuclear club in 1998, the subcontinent’s importance became undeniable. Still, habits are hard to break. America continued its tilt toward Pakistan.
President George W. Bush inaugurated an era of good feelings. India was a natural fit for a president whose term was defined by a global war on terrorism and championing democracy. Bush upgraded relations with India, and our two nations signed a civil nuclear cooperation agreement. As part of the deal, India separated its military and civil nuclear programs, agreed to cooperate with the International Atomic Energy Agency, and shared technology with the United States.