18 November 2026

Beyond the Generals: Non-Policy Officers and Civil-Military Responsibility in the New Information Age

Just Security | Paul Rasmussen, Lewis Wilson

United States military non-policy officers at rank O-6 and below face unprecedented civil-military exposure driven by digital communications and partisan polarization. High-profile incidents include the June arrest of an Air Force major protesting near the U.S. Capitol and Marine Lt. Col. Stuart Scheller's court-martial following his 2021 Facebook video criticizing the Afghanistan withdrawal.

Digital communication blurred professional boundaries. Department of Defense Directive 1344.10, enacted in 2008, governs political conduct alongside Article 88 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice, yet fails to address modern network environments. Incidental political exposure also occurs when operational actions acquire partisan framing, demonstrated by Navy Capt. Brett Crozier's March 30, 2020 memorandum regarding COVID-19 aboard the USS Theodore Roosevelt. These cases highlight how tactical-level leaders incur national security significance before acquiring senior professional military education. Preparing junior and mid-grade officers to navigate constitutional obligations alongside professional neutrality remains vital as social media platforms accelerate political friction.

Comment

The friction between non-policy officers and public political discourse reflects a breakdown in traditional command-and-control containment mechanisms. Department of Defense Directive 1344.10 relied on clear distinctions between active service status and public advocacy, yet networked platforms erode senior leadership's control over unit communications. When operational correspondence such as Captain Brett Crozier's March 2020 memorandum bypasses internal channels, the chain of command loses authority over institutional narrative.

This exposure forces operational commanders to manage external political disruption alongside theatre requirements. Mid-grade leaders possessing direct digital access to civilian audiences convert tactical administrative frictions into immediate political debates. Consequently, routine operational reporting across units like the U.S. Seventh Fleet now carries immediate strategic exposure for combatant commanders.

Strategic Question for Discussion
If operational correspondence like Captain Brett Crozier's 2020 memorandum is immediately amplified by digital networks, which mechanism better protects command authority — updating Department of Defense Directive 1344.10 or decentralising information management to theatre commanders?
The pattern suggests that updating Department of Defense Directive 1344.10 provides limited friction against instant digital dissemination. Institutional authority relies more on preparing mid-grade officers for command-level information dynamics than on restrictive regulations. Experience from the USS Theodore Roosevelt incident indicates that procedural updates cannot outpace real-time networked communication without formal doctrine addressing tactical communications management.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
💬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×