22 November 2026

If AI Takes the Jobs, Who Will Pay the Taxes?

RAND Corporation | Carter C. Price, Monique Martineau, Jeffrey B. Wenger

Artificial intelligence risks displacing 10 to 15 percent of American work hours over the next 15 years, threatening two-thirds of United States federal tax revenue derived from labor. Knowledge workers in law, software development, finance, and research face immediate automation risks. Because individual income and payroll taxes generated 84 percent of federal receipts in 2024, high-earner job losses create severe fiscal deficits.

The top 10 percent of earners contribute 76 percent of individual income tax revenue. Uncompensated labor displacement reduces federal revenue by 1.6 percentage points of gross domestic product. Deflation makes national debt less affordable. Existing tax policy compounds this deficit by levying a 7.65 percent payroll tax exclusively on human labor while permitting accelerated depreciation for corporate automation assets. Proposed stabilizing reforms include replacing employer payroll levies with corporate income taxes, levying progressive per-worker profit taxes, and taxing capital gains as ordinary income to raise over $100 billion per year.

Comment

Federal tax revenue contraction directly threatens long-term funding lines for major defense procurement programmes like the F-35 Lightning II and Virginia-class submarine construction. Because discretionary spending absorbs the immediate impact of federal revenue deficits, declining payroll and income tax receipts compress United States Department of Defense discretionary appropriations relative to mandatory entitlement commitments. A structural drop in individual tax collections forces the Pentagon to rely more heavily on deficit financing, increasing exposure to statutory spending caps under the Statutory Pay-As-You-Go Act of 2010.

The specific mechanism of this fiscal compression operates through the statutory prioritisation of Social Security and Medicare trust funds over discretionary military outlays. When payroll tax receipts fall short of mandatory entitlement obligations, the Congressional Budget Office projects automatic drawdowns from general revenues, directly squeezing procurement accounts like the United States Navy's Shipbuilding and Conversion fund. Consequently, the Pentagon's Next Generation Air Dominance programme faces severe budgetary competition against non-discretionary federal transfer payments.

Strategic Question for Discussion
Which carries greater risk for the United States Department of Defense during prolonged tax revenue declines — delaying major modernization initiatives like the Next Generation Air Dominance programme or absorbing cuts across readiness accounts — and what structural fiscal adjustments tip that balance?
The historical trajectory of federal budget sequestration under the Budget Control Act of 2011 suggests that Congress will force discretionary defense outlays to absorb immediate revenue shortfalls rather than restructure entitlement obligations. In my assessment, this dynamic will force the United States Air Force to delay production schedules for complex initiatives like the Next Generation Air Dominance programme to preserve near-term operational readiness. Consequently, long-term force structure modernization will likely be sacrificed to sustain existing operational commitments.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
💬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×