19 November 2026

The military needs strategic thinkers, not just operators

Defense One | Greg Pollock

Secretary Pete Hegseth rolled out professional military education reforms via a 33-point memorandum and a companion speech at the Naval War College. The guidance misdiagnoses what needs to change in U.S. military culture by prioritizing traditional battlefield warfighting over broader strategic thinking and political outcomes. American forces have historically excelled at tactical execution while struggling to translate military victory into durable political settlements, a shortcoming evident in ongoing operations against Iran.

Deterrence requires integrating military power with diplomatic and economic instruments of statecraft, demanding an intellectual foundation beyond operational maneuvers. While the memorandum includes useful proposals on artificial intelligence and wargaming, shifting oversight to political appointees and eliminating faculty tenure risks politicizing institutions. Successful professional military education must produce strategic leaders capable of advising civilian policymakers and securing enduring national advantage.

Comment

Shifting professional military education oversight from the Joint Staff's J7 directorate to the Undersecretary for Personnel and Readiness alters the institutional insulation that protects curriculum design from short-term partisan churn. When civilian faculty tenure is weakened alongside political appointment adjustments, war colleges risk losing the institutional friction required to challenge prevailing orthodoxy.

Strategic Question for Discussion
How does relocating professional military education oversight to a Senate-confirmed political position alter the ability of institutions like the National War College to challenge prevailing administration assumptions?
The pattern suggests that shifting curriculum authority toward political appointees increases vulnerability to ideological screening. This structural change likely diminishes the candid advisory independence that senior flag officers require before advising civilian leadership on complex contingencies.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
💬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×