20 November 2026

One chair, seven leaders

Brussels Signal | Renata Shipkova

European Council President António Costa proposed the E5+EU2 format on November 13 in Dublin, designating five national leaders and two institutional presidents to represent the continent in potential Ukraine peace talks. The arrangement includes Germany, France, Italy, Poland, and the United Kingdom, alongside the European Commission and Council, though its authority remains contested by the remaining member states.

Lithuanian foreign minister Kęstutis Budrys noted the difficulty of coordinating twenty-seven national positions, while foreign ministers meeting in Brussels on November 16 questioned the mandate and composition of the negotiating team. EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas invoked her institutional treaties to challenge her exclusion from the envoy role, exposing persistent internal frictions. National governments remain reluctant to delegate real political authority or concede national control to a single representative, reflecting foundational tensions within the EU foreign policy architecture.

Comment

The E5+EU2 format exposes the structural incapacity of the European Council to centralise diplomatic representation during acute security crises. Relying on national security advisers from Germany, France, Italy, Poland, and the United Kingdom alongside institutional chiefs creates a committee structure ill-suited for fast-moving peace negotiations. This mirrors the diplomatic fragmentation seen during the 2008 Russo-Georgian War when the French presidency of the Council negotiated independently without a unified EU mandate. Consequently, external actors dealing with the Union face competing domestic veto points rather than a coherent negotiating partner.

Strategic Question for Discussion
How does the reliance on national security advisers within the E5+EU2 format alter the traditional diplomatic authority of the European External Action Service during high-stakes negotiations?
The reliance on national security advisers bypasses the established EEAS architecture and institutionalises national preeminence. This points to a permanent structural preference for intergovernmental bargaining over supranational representation in European crisis management.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
💬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×