20 November 2026

The Tamed Liberal West Doesn’t Understand the Threat of Islam

Chronicles | Daniel McCarthy

George W. Bush launched the invasion of Iraq in 2003 with the bipartisan conviction that deposing Saddam Hussein would establish liberal democracy across the Middle East. Twenty-five years after the 9/11 attacks, Western elites confront demographic decline at home alongside the rapid global expansion of Islam, a faith whose growth in sub-Saharan Africa mirrors its historical spread in North Africa 1,300 years ago.

Modern Westerners view religion as voluntary and subordinate to individual rights, misinterpreting their own Lockean framework as a universal human condition. European states broke from religious conflict only after the 17th-century wars that prompted Thomas Hobbes to write Leviathan in 1651, establishing earthly territorial authority to restrain human vainglory. Muslims did not experience an equivalent historical transition, leaving Islam untamed by Hobbesian or Lockean social-contract philosophy. Consequently, modern liberals routinely direct more hostility toward domestic postliberals than toward unassimilated religious expansion, misjudging the enduring spiritual appeal of an unsecularized faith.

Comment

Modern liberal governance assumes that religious commitment remains subordinate to state-administered civil rights, mirroring the rational utilitarianism outlined in John Locke's Second Treatise of Government. That framework mistakes a historically contingent European settlement for a universal default, blinding state institutions to systems where sacred law supersedes territorial sovereignty.

Strategic Question for Discussion
How does the persistence of pre-Hobbesian political theology within transnational movements challenge the security assumptions embedded in John Locke's Second Treatise of Government?
The pattern suggests that conventional statecraft struggles to deter actors who operate outside secular social-contract frameworks. This points to a persistent vulnerability in border management and internal security.
Share your assessment in the comments below.
πŸ’¬
Ask me
Ask Strategic Study India New chat ×